Score: 8

"Basic but good"

submission: DJ Jester - Classic Flower

date: July 10, 2008

I think it is good sounding, a little too repeatative, but then again, loop. I normally don't hear things like just going up and down scales, but even though it's simple, it isn't really done that much, so it makes it sound a little more original. A good song for your 2cd submission.

Score: 6

"Lots of loops, too many"

submission: Beat On Classic

date: July 2, 2008

I think over time, people's music is able to go into a vast assortmant of ways. With synthesizers and recording programs, there are an infimous array of sounds to chose from. So picking only a few and making repeated loops of them isn't taking control of it. Try taking time on your music, that's what I learned, I submitted my first piece and it got owned by voters, simply because it was not well done.

I didn't vote on your submission because I would be making my submissions in this area seem better. Just try, I am not trying to be mean, just trying to give some criticizm.

Score: 9

"Sounds like santana"

submission: {-^MP^-} To The Future!

date: June 30, 2008

Just the style and sound of the guitar, very good work, it's hard to keep up with someone playing like that on guitar with drums. Honestly, I wish my audio submissions to this site could have that much feeling, and that good of tone. For my actual critisizm, tell frank to try keeping with tempo a little better, it seems like he is just playing randomly in some places, not talking about the shredding, because that really doesn't rely on tempo.

Very good song, good job to you and same to frank.

Score: 9

"Good"

submission: DBG/With a Side of Funk

date: June 6, 2008

Both the songs themselves are great, but I think you should have redone one of them, so they match eachother. Like the end for example is really mixed up, the other songs just stops while this one is going, which would be ok if it went better together.

By the way, how are these songs comming here, no offense, but it's hard for me to think that someone on newgrounds can play the horn great, and the electric guitar, and the bass guitar well.

Score: 8

"A little questionable"

submission: Polk County Prison

date: June 6, 2008

The backbeat of the song, and the end are both from old blues tunes, it sounds good though. I mean, it's blues, the rhythm is normally very basic, but that doesn't mean it's not important. I like blues music, and it sounded good, just a little unoriginal you were, if not, I would have given a 10.

Score: 7

"I've heard funk"

submission: 90 funk

date: June 2, 2008

I don't know why your funk music is like this, or the other funk music on this site, but personally, loops don't sound good to me. I mean, it's not like the end of "Hey Jude", where it keeps being added too and it sounds better, this is just repeated things, and they are so basic. Guitar on plays 2 notes, and the same way the entire time, yes, guitar is a part of funk music. The bassline is also repetative, which is basically the center of funk music. I may seem harsh, but it takes time to create good music, not just half an hour on a computer program.

PS. For those who stroll around and whine about people giving actual critisizm instead of posting "awesome", and "best ever!!!", if you find my review offensive, put an abuse sign on it. If you find my review actually vives critisizm, and you want it to go away, why not making longer reviews yourself.

Score: 9

"Good solo, good song"

submission: Welcome USA

date: December 31, 2007

The song was good, you guys went a lil slow, just neep to keep the beat better, and that's about it. Solo was great, 5/5

Score: 5

"Already done"

submission: Rock-a-Willy

date: December 15, 2007

This is a song out of one of my guitar books, note by note man, I don't know if you knew, but I am not giving you a five just for that. This song is also extremely easy, all done one the first 3 strings, and thier first 3 frets.

Score: 10

"I can picture...."

submission: Pink Jumper (Antil)

date: October 1, 2007

This is a kickass theme song for something, it's got a kickass baseline that most bands wouldn't do, I love bands that don't just focus everything on the singer or lead electric guitar.

Score: 8

"On the right track"

submission: Panarazy [Demo]

date: October 1, 2007

I think this is a great song, but it needs some brushing up, I could hear how the intro got a little messed up, and it's not even the notes, you just need to stop seperating beats so much. But really awesome if you just blend it together more.